Indeterminate Propositions in Prior Analytics I . 41
نویسنده
چکیده
In Analytica Priora I.41 stellt Aristoteles eine bemerkenswerte Behauptung über unbestimmte Aussagen wie ‚A kommt B zu‘ auf. Die Behauptung impliziert, dass solche unbestimmten Aussagen nicht gleichwertig sind zu folgender Ekthesisbedingung: ‚es gibt ein C, so dass B allem C zukommt und A allem C zukommt‘. Anderseits wird oft angenommen, dass unbestimmte Aussagen gleichwertig sind zu partikulären Aussagen wie ‚A kommt einigem B zu‘ und dass diese wiederum gleichwertig sind zur Ekthesisbedingung. Im vorliegenden Artikel werden verschiedene Lösungsansätze für diese Schwierigkeit diskutiert.
منابع مشابه
Pr ecis of Aristotle’s Modal Syllogistic
Aristotle was the founder of modal logic. In his Prior Analytics, he developed a complex system of modal syllogistic. While influential, this system has been disputed since antiquity and is today widely regarded as incoherent or inconsistent. In view of this, Aristotle’s Modal Syllogistic explores the prospects for understanding the modal syllogistic as a coherent and consistent system of modal...
متن کاملPlurality and Distributivity in Yaeyaman Wh-Questions
In Yaeyaman, a critically endangered Japonic language of the Southern Ryukyus, there is a distinction made between singular and plural wh-questions, with plurality indicated by reduplication of the indeterminate (wh) pronoun. I argue that reduplication of the indeterminate is triggered by a morpheme RED that requires the presence of non-atoms in the set of Hamblin alternatives denoted by its si...
متن کاملI-41: Remove of Hydrosalpinx Prior the ART Cycle
Khalaf Y Guy’s Hospital Campus, Kings College London, UK Email: [email protected]
متن کاملA Non-extensional Notion of Conversion in the Organon
this paper is about a special notion of conversion found in Prior Analytics 2. 22, 68a16–21. I hope to show that the notion is worth studying for two reasons: firstly because it is interesting in itself, and secondly because it has implications for the semantics of apropositions (that is, assertoric universal a¶rmative propositions). Let us say that A is a-predicated of B if and only if the apr...
متن کاملServiceability Response of Rehabilitated Unbonded Post-tensioned Indeterminate I-Beams Consisting UHSSCC
The ultra-high strength self-compacting concrete, UHSSCC is the new generation type of concrete with a compressive strength higher than 80MPa. The application of this type of concrete on the serviceability state in CFRP strengthened unbonded post-tensioned indeterminate I-beam is monitored and the results are compared theoretically using different standards. For this aim, full scale I-beam of 9...
متن کامل